Central Lutheran School Photo - Preschool students learn through a balanced curriculum. (Photo taken pre-COVID.)

Top 3 Best New Haven Private Elementary Schools (2025)

For the 2025 school year, there are 6 private elementary schools serving 1,059 students in New Haven, IN.
The top ranked private elementary schools in New Haven, IN include Central Lutheran School, St. John The Baptist School, and St. Louis Academy.
The average acceptance rate is 99%, which is higher than the Indiana private elementary school average acceptance rate of 88%.
83% of private elementary schools in New Haven, IN are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic and Amish).

Top Ranked New Haven Private Elementary Schools (2025)

School
Location
Grades
Students
Central Lutheran School
Central Lutheran School Photo - Preschool students learn through a balanced curriculum. (Photo taken pre-COVID.)
(Lutheran Church Missouri Synod)
(5)
900 Green St
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 493-2502
Grades: PK-8
| 357 students
St. John The Baptist School
(Catholic)
204 S Rufus St
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 749-9903
Grades: PK-8
| 245 students
St. Louis Academy
(Catholic)
15529 Lincoln Hwy E
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 749-5815
Grades: PK-8
| 126 students
Maumee Valley School
(Amish)
7630 Roberts Rd
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 258-0516
Grades: 1-8
| 81 students
Milan Center School
(Amish)
14702 Doty Rd
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 413-4311
Grades: 1-8
| 116 students
Peace Montessori
Montessori School
2315 Long Rd
New Haven, IN 46774
(260) 493-3114
Grades: PK-12
| 134 students

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top ranked private elementary schools in New Haven, IN?
The top ranked private elementary schools in New Haven, IN include Central Lutheran School, St. John The Baptist School, and St. Louis Academy.
How many private elementary schools are located in New Haven?
6 private elementary schools are located in New Haven.
How diverse are private elementary schools in New Haven?
New Haven private elementary schools are approximately 6% minority students, which is lower than the Indiana private school average of 25%.
What percentage of private elementary schools are religiously affiliated in New Haven?
83% of private elementary schools in New Haven are religiously affiliated (most commonly Catholic and Amish).

Recent Articles

A Parent's Guide To Understanding High School Teaching Methods
A Parent's Guide To Understanding High School Teaching Methods
This comprehensive guide helps parents navigate the various teaching methods used in today's high school classrooms. By understanding these approaches, you'll be better equipped to support your teen's learning journey, communicate effectively with teachers, and create a complementary learning environment at home.
Social Emotional Learning: Education's Hidden Symphony
February 08, 2025
Social Emotional Learning: Education's Hidden Symphony
A musician's perspective on Social Emotional Learning reveals how this educational framework orchestrates success through five essential emotional competencies.
A Roadmap For Starting A Private School
January 24, 2025
A Roadmap For Starting A Private School
Use this roadmap as a set of talking points with your trusted mentors and professionals to start the private school of your dreams. You're not alone. Over the years, hundreds of folks like you have had the same dream. From Quintilian to Maria Montessori to Lucy Madeira Wing, visionary educators have established schools to teach according to their beliefs and methodologies.